New Delhi: A consumer commission in Kerala has directed the railway administration to pay ₹25,000 in compensation to a passenger whose RAC ticket was downgraded to Waiting List-1 and automatically cancelled before his journey. The Malappuram District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission held the railway administration responsible for deficiency in service and unfair trade practices.
The passenger, who was travelling from Mumbai to Kerala due to an emergency, had originally booked a ticket with an RAC-44 status. However, after Indian Railways replaced the Third AC (3A) coach with a Third AC Economy (3E) coach, his reservation status was changed to Waiting List-1. The ticket was subsequently cancelled without prior notification, forcing him to purchase another ticket for the same train.
Passenger Forced to Book Another Ticket After Cancellation
The case concerns Yadukrishnan C, a law student at KC Law College in Mumbai, who booked a ticket through IRCTC for Train No. 16345, the Netravati Express, travelling from Lokmanya Tilak Terminus to Kayamkulam Junction in Kerala.
At the time of booking, his ticket showed a waiting list position of 77, while the current reservation status had improved to RAC-44.
However, after the reservation chart was prepared, the status changed to Waiting List-1, following which the railway system automatically cancelled the ticket. The passenger maintained that he had neither requested the cancellation nor received any advance information about the change in reservation status.
He had paid ₹1,819, including GST, for the original ticket. Following cancellation, the railway deducted ₹65 as clerkage charges and refunded ₹1,730.
With his journey at risk, the passenger booked another ticket on the same Netravati Express on September 9, 2024. This time, he had to pay ₹2,339, including GST.
Railway Cites Replacement of Third AC Coach
During the proceedings, the railway administration argued that operational requirements had necessitated replacing the Third AC (3A) coach with a Third AC Economy (3E) coach.
According to the railway, the change required the reallocation of seats and reservations for passengers who had already booked tickets. This reportedly affected the reservation status of certain passengers.
The railway also maintained that RAC status does not guarantee a confirmed berth and questioned whether the consumer commission had jurisdiction to hear the dispute, arguing that the matter should instead be taken up before the Railway Claims Tribunal.
IRCTC, meanwhile, argued that its responsibility was limited to providing the online ticket-booking platform. It clarified that reservation charts, seat allocation, ticket cancellation and deduction of clerkage charges were controlled by the railway administration.
RTI Responses Raise Questions Over Railway’s Decision
The consumer commission examined the passenger’s ticket records, email correspondence and responses obtained through the Right to Information (RTI) process.
The RTI responses did not establish any clear railway policy authorising the downgrade of an RAC-44 ticket to Waiting List-1 under the circumstances.
The commission observed that although the railway acknowledged changing the coach configuration, it failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for why the passenger’s reservation status had to be downgraded and the ticket automatically cancelled.
It also took note of the fact that the passenger was not informed before the cancellation.
The commission concluded that changing the status of an RAC ticket to waiting list without adequate justification, cancelling it automatically and deducting ₹65 from the refund amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.
Railway Ordered to Pay ₹25,000 Within 45 Days
The Malappuram District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission directed the railway administration to pay ₹20,000 as compensation for the mental agony and physical inconvenience suffered by the passenger.
An additional ₹5,000 was awarded towards litigation expenses, taking the total compensation to ₹25,000.
The commission gave the Additional General Manager of Central Railway 45 days to comply with the order. If the payment is not made within the stipulated period, the railway will have to pay annual interest at 9 per cent on the entire amount from the date of the order until payment.
The case was heard by Commission President Mohanadhasan K, along with members Preethi Sivaraman C and Mohammed Ismail CV.
The commission also clarified that IRCTC could not be held responsible because the decision to change the reservation status and cancel the ticket was outside its control.
